How to Get More Google Reviews
The ask, the link and the timing, what Google's policy allows and bans, and what 228 Google reviews looked like at my own venue.
I asked ChatGPT and Gemini the same 8 questions about hiring marketing help around Baltimore, 4 times each. In those 64 answers my own business came up 2 times, both on Gemini, and not once on ChatGPT.
Showing up in ChatGPT is a practice with three parts, and none of them is a trick. OpenAI's crawler can read your website, your business facts match everywhere they appear, and other places on the web say you exist. That's the practice. Nobody can promise the result, me included.
ChatGPT can answer from what it already knows, or it can search the web and pull from pages. For the second kind OpenAI runs a crawler called OAI-SearchBot, and that's the part a business can do something about.
Who helps local businesses show up in ChatGPT answers? I do, through Another Monday, a Baltimore marketing agency. AI search optimization comes with every monthly plan, and I check how each client shows up in AI answers every month. I measured my own site in October 2026 too, and in 32 answers to my core questions ChatGPT never named it.
You'll see this work called answer engine optimization, AEO, or generative engine optimization, GEO. Some say AI visibility. It's the same job under every label, and it sits on top of traditional SEO. It doesn't replace it.
Permission to read it, first. OpenAI's own page on its crawlers says OAI-SearchBot is used to surface websites in ChatGPT's search features, and that "Sites that are opted out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers". It recommends allowing the crawler in your robots.txt file and allowing requests from its published IP ranges. I read the OpenAI crawler documentation on November 5, 2026.
That page also describes GPTBot, which is a different crawler. It's used to gather content that may be used to train OpenAI's models, and OpenAI says each setting is independent of the others. So blocking one doesn't block the other, and a business can make that choice for each.
My own robots.txt is two working lines, User-agent: * and Allow: /, so it allows
every crawler, OAI-SearchBot included. That's all the permission takes. It also isn't proof that ChatGPT
has read my pages, and I'm not claiming it has.
Google's side is just as plain. Its page on AI features in Search says there are "no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode", and that the best practices for SEO remain relevant. A page also has to be indexed and eligible to appear in Google search results with a snippet to be a supporting link. I read Google's guidance on AI features the same day. So the first job for Google's AI answers is the old one, a page Google can crawl, index and show.
Then there's the rest of the web. On November 5, 2026 I searched this exact question, and Google AI Overviews listed eleven sources. One was a Reddit thread. Four were YouTube videos, one was a LinkedIn post and five were small agency or consultant blogs. None was OpenAI. That's one search on one day, so I'm not drawing a rule from it. It does fit what I'd expect, that AI answers pull from places across the web and not only from the business being asked about, which is why Reddit threads and directory listings belong on the checklist below.
In October 2026 my in-house tracker asked the ChatGPT app and the Gemini app 8 questions an owner in or around Baltimore might type while looking for marketing help. Who should I hire for SEO. Who builds websites for small businesses. Who can manage my Google Business Profile. Each question went in 4 times on each app, for 32 answers per app and 64 in all, and it counted the ones that named Another Monday. The count covers those core questions only, and questions with my business name in them are left out, because they'd name me by default.
That's 3% of answers, and the 95% range around it runs from 0 to 9%. The range comes from resampling the questions, which is how you avoid sounding surer than 64 answers allow.
It's a small sample from one month, and these tools give a different answer from one ask to the next. So read it as a baseline and not a verdict. I'm showing it anyway because a business that sells this work should be willing to publish its own number, and mine is low. One more detail, so the zero isn't read as more than it is. Outside those 64, on a longer question about whether SEO is worth it for a home service business and which Baltimore agency to use, ChatGPT did name Another Monday in 1 of 4 asks. The tracker runs every month, so the next count will show whether anything I change moves it.
These are the eight I'd look at, in the order I'd look. Each one is in your control, and each has a way to see the answer in your own browser. None of them guarantees a mention. They're the work, and they happen to be what makes a business easier for AI tools to read, verify and repeat.
| Check | Why it matters | How to see it yourself |
|---|---|---|
| Crawlers are allowed in | OpenAI's search crawler is OAI-SearchBot, and a site that blocks it won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers. | Open yourdomain.com/robots.txt. A line that says Disallow: / under User-agent: * or under OAI-SearchBot is a closed door. |
| Your pages are indexed on Google | Google says a page has to be indexed and eligible to show in Search with a snippet before it can be a supporting link in its AI answers. | Search site:yourdomain.com on Google. Pages that are missing there need fixing before anything else on this list. |
| Consistent business information everywhere | Your business name, address and phone number are the facts an AI tool has to check against each other. When two listings disagree, there is nothing safe to repeat. | Put your website, Google Business Profile, Bing Places and one directory side by side and compare the three lines letter by letter. |
| Each page answers one question in its first sentence | Content that answers the customer question directly is easy to lift, for a person skimming or a tool quoting. | Read the first sentence of every service page and FAQ answer on its own. If it only makes sense after the heading, rewrite it. |
| Your profile and reviews are current | A Google Business Profile with real, recent reviews is the clearest public record of what you do. I can show it helps customers, and I cannot show ChatGPT counts it. | Open your own profile on a phone, signed out. Count the reviews from the last 90 days. |
| Someone besides you says you exist | AI answers lean on sources across the web, and not only on the business being asked about. A directory listing or a local mention is a second voice. | Search your business name in quotes and read past page one. Note every site that is not yours. |
| Structured data matches the page | Schema markup states your name, services and hours in a form software reads. I treat it as housekeeping for Google, and I have not seen proof that ChatGPT reads it. | Paste a service page into Google's Rich Results Test and compare every field it finds to the visible page. |
| You have asked it yourself | The only way to know whether a tool names you is to ask it, more than once, because answers change between asks. | Write eight questions a customer would type. Ask each one on three different days. Keep a dated list of who gets named. |
Two of those eight, the profile and the reviews, have their own posts. The Google Business Profile checklist covers the listing, and the review ask I use covers the reviews. The wider order of work is in local SEO for a small business, and the local SEO checklist runs the same kind of pass on the rest of the site.
If your business isn't on Google at all yet, start there. Why your business isn't showing up on Google has the checks, and none of the AI work above lands on a page Google can't find.
A guaranteed mention. If someone promises your business will be named in ChatGPT, ask how they'd know. The tool decides, and the answers change between asks. I can't promise it, and I don't think anybody outside OpenAI can.
Pages written for the machine and not the customer. Google says no special optimizations are needed for its AI features, and I'd apply the same test to anyone selling a trick. A page a customer finds useful is the one worth writing.
A pitch that treats this as brand new. Much of it is the same work as SEO, with a closer eye on consistency and on being quoted. Ask any marketing agency which of the eight checks its proposal covers.
You can run the eight checks yourself in an afternoon. The ones that take longer are the pages themselves, written so the first sentence answers the customer, and keeping every listing identical as the business changes.
That's work I do as a Baltimore SEO company. AI search optimization is a row on every monthly plan, with Google Business Profile management and the website built inside it. Plans start at $800 a month, with a 90-day foundation period and month to month after that. I check how you show up in AI answers each month and tell you what I find, including when it's nothing.
Let's have a conversation about your business, what the AI tools say about you today and which of the eight I'd fix first.
Give me your website address and the town you serve, and I'll tell you what I'd check first for ChatGPT and Google. I can reply within a few hours.
Last 90 days, across the sites and Search Console/GA4 accounts Another Monday manages. Figures as of November 2026.
Getting your business to show up in ChatGPT starts with making your website readable to OpenAI's search crawler, keeping your name, address and phone number identical everywhere they appear, and having other sites on the web mention you. None of that guarantees a mention. It makes your business easier for an AI tool to find, check and repeat.
I don't know of any way to pay for a place in ChatGPT's answers, and anyone who sells one should show you where OpenAI says it exists. What a business can do is allow OpenAI's search crawler in, publish clear pages and keep its information consistent across the web.
Blocking GPTBot and blocking OAI-SearchBot are two separate choices, and OpenAI says the settings are independent of each other. GPTBot is used to crawl content that may be used in training its models, and OAI-SearchBot is the one used to surface sites in ChatGPT's search features, so a business that wants to appear in ChatGPT search answers needs OAI-SearchBot allowed.
Traditional SEO still matters, because Google says SEO best practices remain relevant for AI Overviews and AI Mode, and OpenAI's crawler also needs pages it is allowed to read. A site Google can't crawl or index is a weak starting point for any AI tool that searches the web.
Answer engine optimization, or AEO, is the work of making your business easy for AI tools and search engines to quote in an answer. You'll also see it called generative engine optimization, GEO, or AI visibility. The work overlaps heavily with SEO: clear pages, consistent facts and a real presence on other sites.
You can check whether ChatGPT mentions your business by asking it the questions a customer would type, such as who to hire for your service in your town. Ask each question several times on different days and write down who gets named, because answers change from one ask to the next.
Reviews are worth having because customers read them, and I can't show that they change what ChatGPT says. A Google Business Profile with real, recent reviews is still the strongest public record most local businesses have, so I'd keep earning them either way.
Schema markup is structured data that states your business facts in a form software can read, and I haven't seen proof that ChatGPT uses it. Google documents structured data for its own search features, so it's worth getting right and keeping accurate, as long as it matches what the page says.
No, I can't guarantee that your business will show up in ChatGPT, and nobody outside OpenAI can. My own site was named in 2 of 64 AI answers in October 2026 and in none of the 32 ChatGPT answers, which is why I only promise the work.
AI search optimization is a row on every Another Monday plan and isn't priced as a separate add-on. Plans start at $800 a month, with a 90-day foundation period and month to month after that, and I check how clients show up in AI answers every month.
A free 30-minute strategy session with the person who'd be doing the work. Bring your website address and the town you serve.
¡También Hablamos Español!